Compare Backhoe Loader. Choose Smarter.
JCB 3DX Xtra VS Tata Hitachi Shinrai Comparison
JCB 3DX Xtra
₹ 25.97 L - 32.99 L
VS
Tata Hitachi Shinrai
₹ 29 L - 31 L
Compare backhoe loader helps you make an informed purchase decision.
JCB 3DX Xtra
From ₹ 25.97 Lakh
Tata Hitachi Shinrai
From ₹ 29 Lakh
Engine
Model
JCB 430
Shinrai Prime / Power 4 (variant-dependent)
Model
JCB 430
Shinrai Prime / Power 4 (variant-dependent)
Engine Displacement
3000 cc
3620 cc
Engine Displacement
3000 cc
3620 cc
Engine Power
74 HP
74 HP
Engine Power
74 HP
74 HP
Maximum Torque
400 Nm
305 Nm
Maximum Torque
400 Nm
305 Nm
Fuel Type
Diesel
Diesel
Fuel Type
Diesel
Diesel
Transmission Type
-
Synchro‑shuttle / 4F + 4R gears
Transmission Type
-
Synchro‑shuttle / 4F + 4R gears
Overall Dimension & Weight
Max Operating Weight
7630 kg
7800 kg
Max Operating Weight
7630 kg
7800 kg
Transport Length
6100 mm
5850 mm
Transport Length
6100 mm
5850 mm
Width Over Stabilizer/Bucket
2350 mm
2150 mm
Width Over Stabilizer/Bucket
2350 mm
2150 mm
Wheel Base
-
-
Wheel Base
-
-
Minimum Ground Clearance
310 mm
320 mm
Minimum Ground Clearance
310 mm
320 mm
Height Of Top Of Cabin
2870 mm
3050 mm
Height Of Top Of Cabin
2870 mm
3050 mm
Loader General
Dump Height
2930 mm
2500 mm
Dump Height
2930 mm
2500 mm
Max Pay Load
1800 kg
1920 kg
Max Pay Load
1800 kg
1920 kg
Load Over Height
3370 mm
2500 mm
Load Over Height
3370 mm
2500 mm
Dump Angle
41 degree
43 degree
Dump Angle
41 degree
43 degree
Hinge Pin Height
3640 mm
2500 mm
Hinge Pin Height
3640 mm
2500 mm
Loader Arm Breakout Force
5516 kgf
2700 kgf
Loader Arm Breakout Force
5516 kgf
2700 kgf
Max Reach At Full Height
930 mm
1341 mm
Max Reach At Full Height
930 mm
1341 mm
Loader Bucket Capacity
1 Cu.m
0.26 Cu.m
Loader Bucket Capacity
1 Cu.m
0.26 Cu.m
Bucket Breakout Force
6264 kgf
2800 kgf
Bucket Breakout Force
6264 kgf
2800 kgf
Backhoe
Max Dig Depth
5050 mm
4700 mm
Max Dig Depth
5050 mm
4700 mm
Max Load Over Height
4350 mm
3000 mm
Max Load Over Height
4350 mm
3000 mm
Max Working Height
6010 mm
4400 mm
Max Working Height
6010 mm
4400 mm
Backhoe Bucket Capacity
0.3 Cu.m
1.1 Cu.m
Backhoe Bucket Capacity
0.3 Cu.m
1.1 Cu.m
Bucket Rotation
185 mm
180 mm
Bucket Rotation
185 mm
180 mm
Dipper Tear Out Force
3341 kgf
4300 kgf
Dipper Tear Out Force
3341 kgf
4300 kgf
Max Lift Capacity
1584 kg
1920 kg
Max Lift Capacity
1584 kg
1920 kg
Hydraulic System
Pump Type
Variable displacement hydraulic pump
Tandem Gear / Variable Displacement Pump
Pump Type
Variable displacement hydraulic pump
Tandem Gear / Variable Displacement Pump
Pump Flow
148 Lpm
120 Lpm
Pump Flow
148 Lpm
120 Lpm
System Pressure
160
210
System Pressure
160
210
Hydraulic Oil
92 Ltr
86 Ltr
Hydraulic Oil
92 Ltr
86 Ltr
Service Capacities
Engine Oil
15 Ltr
11 Ltr
Engine Oil
15 Ltr
11 Ltr
Rear Axle Oil
20 Ltr
6 Ltr
Rear Axle Oil
20 Ltr
6 Ltr
Transmission Oil
17.5 Ltr
22 Ltr
Transmission Oil
17.5 Ltr
22 Ltr
Hydraulic Oil
92 Ltr
86 Ltr
Hydraulic Oil
92 Ltr
86 Ltr
Fuel Tank
128 Ltr
130 Ltr
Fuel Tank
128 Ltr
130 Ltr
Coolant Oil
20.5 Ltr
15 Ltr
Coolant Oil
20.5 Ltr
15 Ltr
Steering & Brakes
Steering Type
Power track steering
Power Steering (articulated / hydrostatic)
Steering Type
Power track steering
Power Steering (articulated / hydrostatic)
Turning Circle Diameter
9700 mm
5200 mm
Turning Circle Diameter
9700 mm
5200 mm
System Pressure
160
210
System Pressure
160
210
Service Brake Type
JCB ‘Q’ brakes, hydraulically actuated, dual line, self adjusting (compensated), oil immersed, multi-disc type on the rear axle, well protected from dirt, water etc. requiring no maintenance. Operated
Oil-immersed Wet Disc Brakes
Service Brake Type
JCB ‘Q’ brakes, hydraulically actuated, dual line, self adjusting (compensated), oil immersed, multi-disc type on the rear axle, well protected from dirt, water etc. requiring no maintenance. Operated
Oil-immersed Wet Disc Brakes
Parking Brakes
Hand operated, disc brakes on rear axle input disc
Mechanical / Hand-operated
Parking Brakes
Hand operated, disc brakes on rear axle input disc
Mechanical / Hand-operated
Tyres & Axle
Standard Front Type
9 x 16 - 16 PR
12.5–20
Standard Front Type
9 x 16 - 16 PR
12.5–20
Standard Rear Type
16.9 x 28-12 PR
19.5–24
Standard Rear Type
16.9 x 28-12 PR
19.5–24
Rear Axle Description
Drive axle rigidly mounted, incorporates JCB Max-Trac torque proportioning differential, driven by short propshaft from gear box.
Heavy-duty, fully floating
Rear Axle Description
Drive axle rigidly mounted, incorporates JCB Max-Trac torque proportioning differential, driven by short propshaft from gear box.
Heavy-duty, fully floating
Front Axle Description
Steer axle, centrally pivoted, with oscillation angle of 16º
Oscillating, rigid / semi-floating
Front Axle Description
Steer axle, centrally pivoted, with oscillation angle of 16º
Oscillating, rigid / semi-floating
Electrical & General
Battery Voltage
12 V
12 V
Battery Voltage
12 V
12 V
Max Forward Speed
40 Km/h
32 Km/h
Max Forward Speed
40 Km/h
32 Km/h
Max Reverse Speed
12 Km/h
22 Km/h
Max Reverse Speed
12 Km/h
22 Km/h
JCB 3DX Xtra
Pros
- Powerful Stage 5‑430 diesel engine with ~440 Nm torque delivers strong digging and loading ability.
- Up to ~10 % lower fuel consumption compared with older models due to features like Auto Stop, Auto Idle, and variable displacement hydraulics.
- Easy Shift Gear and Semi‑Kick Down Switch make gear changes smoother.
Tata Hitachi Shinrai
Pros
- Shinrai models (especially Power 4 and Prime) are engineered for enhanced fuel efficiency, helping reduce running costs on longer jobs.
- Many Shinrai variants use an advanced hydraulic setup with oil‑immersed wet disc brakes and effective gear/tandem pumps that help smooth and reliable hydro performance.
- Shinrai Power 4 and higher variants offer great digging depth (~5003 mm) and strong breakout forces, making them capable in excavation work.
